Monday 28 August 2023

The One Rōnin… Castle of Wind and Clouds (1928), with Stephen Horne and Frank Bockius, Silent Film Days Bonn 2023


A terrible plot is forged around a castle in the south. Good and loyal subjects already fell under the hand of the devils…


Another journey of discovery and a startling film produced by the director of A Page of Madness (1926), Teinosuke Kinugasa, and directed by Toko (aka Fujie) Yamazaki making this the first Japanese silent I’ve seen directed by a woman. Castle… aka Fûun jôshi was made for Kinugasa, part of the Shimogamo studio, it’s a stylish jidai geki, a Japanese period drama involving a samurai clan in this case one poisoned by treachery in which a lone warrior must put honour above his own interests and loyalty to authority above love all and, of course, he must fight.


Almost as soon as the cameras started rolling, the genre made it to screen in Kōchiyama to Nao-zamurai (1916) and was well established by the twenties, flourishing later with classics such as The 47 Ronin (1941), Rashomon (1950) and Seven Samurai (1954). It’s the Japanese equivalent of the western or chivalric tale, honour and duty aligned to bravery, love and combat skill… lone heroes making a difference. The highpoint of any such film is the action but also the moral force painful decisions made in the name of duty something we all relate to.


The film begins and ends with similar shots of a man on horseback, riding down/up the same spiral path from the land beyond all with a gorgeous pink tint. It’s a young man, Shinhachi (Chojiro Hayashi), who has returned home from years of training in the capital, to the land he grew up in and his head is filled with lyrical thoughts of the land, the light and his beautiful fiancée Chigusa (Akiko Chihaya) who has pledged to wait as long as it takes, lonely and sad, until you come back…


Chojiro Hayashi


He is met by his elder brother Einoshin (Sôroku Kazama) and informed that “storm and turmoil await” as the clan is being poisoned by their treacherous uncle, Sannosuke (Ippei Soma). Hayashi, later Kazuo Hasegawa, was just twenty and at the start of a huge film career stretching over 300 films from 1927 to 1968. Here his persona is that of a bidanshi, an androgynous youth – literally “beautiful boy” – in a tradition that stretches way back into Japanese literature and is very “gender” as my daughter might say as this guy can fight; a peacock with a dazzling blade (make of that what you will…).


By contrast Sannosuke is a gurning mask of evil superbly pantomimed by Soma who pulls the eye with dark, almost comic malevolence but whilst these characterisations may seem black and white there’s more graduated tints around the head of the clan, Lord Hachiya Teruaki (Keinosuke Sawada as Myoichiro Ozawa), a tyrant and yet with a sense of fairness all his own. He is unaware of the machinations against him, distracted by orgies and festivities, revelling in lust and luxury.


If you really love her, kill your rival and she will return to your arms…


Akiko Chihaya

Shinhachi is reunited with his sweetheart but in the Lord’s court where he has taken her as one of his concubines… Sannosuke immediately tries to take advantage of the young man’s despair, urging him to kill their leader and take his love back. Shinhachi is however, steadfast and not the hot-headed young samurai Sannosuke hopes, warrior he is though and calm in the midst of conflict and hand to hand combat: I am willing to give my life for our Lord and our clan. The long, poetic intertitles are perhaps a reflection of the benshi-style narration that would have accompanied the film’s original screenings.


Angered by Shinhachi’s unyielding loyalty, Sannosuke arranges for a group of assassins to despatch him but things do not work out as he planned as the young man holds them off before being joined by another martial arts expert from the clan Nikaido Juppeita (Shinkuro Masamune) who, after helping despatch the assassins in a set piece fight that wouldn’t look out of place in many a later film, warns him of the escalating danger. 


Meanwhile our young hero’s brother Einoshin’s illness is getting worse as Shinhachi goes home to see him and his mother (Yoshie Nakagawa). This film’s all heart as well as action and the emotional sacrifices to be made only heighten the dramatic impact of the core messages about discipline and loyalty.

They're outnumbered one-to-nine...

My body is the sacrifice of my desperate love. But my soul is always with you.


Shinhachi plays the flute outside of Chigusa’s quarters and his love hears him… the two exchange words of resigned longing… Then walking in the grounds, he encounters a group of assassins who have tried to kill the Lord, he fights them off using his flute and superior technique but the next day is accused of being one of them by the Lord’s guards and asked to prove his innocence or commit hara-kiri. To protect the family’s honour and buy his brother time, Einoshin kills himself, certain f his brother’s innocence and pleading for him to always stay loyal to their Lord.


You spiteful bandits, meet my martial art! Be ready.


This the scene is set for more superbly choreographed battles as Shinhachi fights for his love, his honour and his clan as the full extent of Sannosuke’s plan are revealed and well, you just have to see it all for yourself. The direction is flowing and the sense of place so well maintained with cinematography from Eiji [Eiichi] Tsuburaya who went on to have a huge career including the development of special effects, he was co-creator of the Godzilla and Ultraman franchises, and some 300 films.



Stephen Horne and Frank Bockius have martial, musical discipline of their own and armed with flute, piano and a multitude of objects to hit, played along with the action and the emotion. Ninjas of silent film accompaniment, you hear them when they want you too but are otherwise seamlessly invisible within the whole experience of a screening, loyal, as Shinhachi to the Prince, to the art on screen. They played a blinder and I really hope to see this film and their music in the UK sometime.


Another special discovery courtesy of Bonn. As I said, next year it’s a date!


Shinkuro Masamune
Ippei Soma
Chojiro Hayashi, Yoshie Nakagawa and Sôroku Kazama
Keinosuke Sawada
Akiko Chihaya



No comments:

Post a Comment